All posts by Dr. Robin Starbuck

About Dr. Robin Starbuck

Professor of English 1973 M.A., New York University 1989 Ph.D., New York University Linguistics

Karma, reincarnation, cause & effect -RA

Cause and effect exist because of time and space. If there were no time and space, there would not be cause and effect. In reality there is no time and space and there’s no cause and effect. But in the relative world there is. Cause and effect is another name for the law of retribution. For as you sow, so shall you reap or the law of karma. And as long as you are under that law, you have to deal with the God of that law. That God is called Ishvara in Hindu, Jehovah in the Hebrew religion, Allah in Mohammed religion, and it goes by many other names.

Those Gods exist as long as you believe that you are the body-mind phenomena. And so does cause and effect. For every action there is an opposite and equal reaction. That’s the law of physics. It’s the same as the law of cause and effect. Everything you do ends up in a result, there’s no escape from it. Unless you turn within and you no longer react to anything. Then you transcend the law and become free. But as long as we are still body conscious, we are under that law.

This is how it works. If you want to grow oranges and you do not know anything about seeds, you would grab a lemon seed, plant it in the ground and expect an orange tree to grow. The cause is the planting of the lemon seed. The effect, the lemon tree. The seed is planted in the earth. The earth is your mind and the seeds are your thoughts. And the effect is the result you get from planting seeds. So you plant a lemon seed and a lemon tree grows. But then you start crying and screaming about it, “I wanted oranges,” you say, “I demand oranges.” And you have a tantrum, you have a fit. Nobody cares. You planted the seeds and this is what you’re getting as a result. Lemons. Of course you can always make lemonade, but you wanted oranges. So why did you plant a lemon seed? You don’t know. Maybe you planted a lemon seed in a previous life. You set up the cause at that time. For the effect can back to you many lifetimes from now, as an orange tree, as a lemon tree rather. And you’ll still scream, “Why did I plant a lemon seed, I wanted oranges instead.” So it is when we see things we do not understand. For instance, when Mahatma Ghandi died, he got shot, why would an honorable man like that get shot? The last word he said to his attacker was, “I forgive you and thank you my son.” For he realized that in some other life he had set the cause in motion. And this is the effect he gets back. This is called “Delayed Karma.”

Now there’s instant karma. Like when you step on the edge of a rake. You step on a rake, what happens? It hits you in the head. That’s called instant karma. Who takes care of this karma? The God of karma is, Ishvara, Allah, Jehovah. It is he who hands out what karma you’re going to experience in each life.

Let’s take another example. Henry invites me to his house. I come into Henry’s house and I go to the refrigerator. I say, “What’s to eat?” I eat him out of house and home. Then I say Henry can I borrow your car? And Henry’s a good guy and he says, “sure.” So I borrow his car and I wreck his car. Break his headlights, his windshield and come back and park it like nothing happened. And Henry being the good guy that he is, doesn’t say anything. Then I say, “Henry can you lend me five hundred dollars?” So Henry being a good guy says, “sure.” And I never expect to pay him back, I just take his money. Now what happens?

By not reacting, Henry becomes neutral. When you’re neutral, you do not accrue karma again. You’re finished with that part of your life. When you react you accrue karma. What happens to me? I’ve got to experience the effect sometime, somehow, of what I’ve done to Henry. It’s got to come back to me somehow. Maybe not even in this lifetime, but it will come back, there’s no escape. This is why when we see certain things in life and we do not understand, we should never judge because everything is working out like it’s supposed to. All is well and everything is unfolding as it should.

Robert Adams

Transcript 23
The Law Of Cause And Effect
11th November, 1990

Different answers to same question -RA

Humans get angry. Therefore when you’ve reached self-realization, do you still have feelings of anger, of rage, or outrage?

A question like this is usually asked by a seeker or a disciple. A devotee couldn’t care less. When you ask a question like this you’re asking from the viewpoint of the ajnani, and there are different answers. It’s very paradoxical.

It reminds me of the time I was initiated by Paramahansa Yogananda in self- realization when I was 17, prior to going to India to see Ramana Maharshi. And during the initiation I was on my knees and he put his hand on my head and he said, “Robert, do you promise to love me no matter what I do, or no matter what you think you see me do?” I hesitated. I said to myself, “What is he going to do? Is he going to kill somebody, and wants me to love him no matter what he does?” But then I also realized that I didn’t have all the answers. So I said, “Yes.”

It’s only by being around two or three months that I realized what he meant. He reacted differently to different people, to different personalities. It was Christmas and he was living with the monks in Encinitas at that time. So I recall one monk came over to him and said, “Master,” they called him Master, “may I go visit my family at Christmas time? I’ll be gone two weeks.” He became very sweet and he said, “Of course you can. You should see your family. They miss you. Go and have a good time and come back in two weeks.”

Then somebody else came and kneeled before him and he said, “Master, may I go see my family during Christmas?” He became outraged and started screaming at the monk and said, “How dare you ask me a question like this. Why do you want to see your family? They don’t want to see you. Of course you can’t go. Don’t ask stupid questions. Go back to your quarters,” This was the dilemma, same questions different answers.

I consequently realized that he was able to read into the person. He knew exactly what was going on with each person. He couldn’t possibly give the same answer to two different people. He realized the first person had a loving family, and the first person had high self-esteem, so it wouldn’t matter where the person goes. Their heart is always on truth, on reality, on God. But the second person had a low self-esteem, and if he left he would be dragged by the powers of maya back into reality, of materiality that is, the reality of materiality and he probably wouldn’t even come back again. That’s why he gave that answer.

Robert Adams

Transcript 35
Does a Sage get Angry?
January 6th, 1991

Why pit paths against each other?

I was so reluctant to respond because I just can’t see any reason under the sun to pit one’s spiritual path against another’s and vehemently teach it.

Infinity certainly has enough infinititude to graciously allow multifarious paths! Millions of people are and have been enjoying great discovery, revelation and – dare I say – enlightenment from a well-honed progressive path or a no-compromise direct path.

Why not choose your path, knowing it’s helped millions and allow in your heart the fact that “the other” path has also helped millions? In the ginormous Heart of Love there’s gotta be a place for those who prove with their very lives that Spirit is All – just like you do.

Do not listen to me -RA

If you want peace of mind stop reacting to life’s situations. Turn within to yourself. Nothing can keep you back from knowing yourself except you. Know yourself! Who am I? Where did I come from? What is the cause of the I? These questions must be pondered within yourself and inquired within the self over and over again. In all situations at all times. Do not think about what I’m saying to you. When you think about it you spoil it. Do not accept anything I’m saying to you. If you accept it there will be a fight within yourself. Your ego will fight you at every turn. So how are you to react to me? You’re not to react to me at all. Listen to the words I speak to you. Just become still within yourself. Never attempt to analyze anything I say. Empty yourself, and the truth of life will be revealed to you.

Robert Adams

Transcript 225
Who Were You Before
You Were Born?
21st February, 1993

Objections re happiness teaching JK

Question: We are happy with our beliefs and traditions based on the doctrines of Jesus; whereas, in your country, India, there are millions who are far from being happy. All that you are telling us, the Christ taught two thousand years ago. What is the use of your preaching to us instead of to your own countrymen?

KRISHNAMURTI: Thought does not belong to any nation or to any race. (Applause) Reality is not conditioned by religious or racial distinctions; and because the questioner has divided the world into Christian and Hindu, into India and Argentina, he has helped to create misery and suffering in the world. (Applause) When I talk in India about nationalism, they say to me, Go to England and tell the people there that nationalism is stupid, because England is pre venting us from living. (Laughter) And when I come here you tell me, Go somewhere else and leave us with our own belief and religion. Do not disturb us. (Laughter)

If your own beliefs and traditions satisfy you, then you will not listen to what I say, because your traditions and your beliefs are shelters under which you take cover in time of trouble. You dont want to face life, therefore you say, I am satisfied; don disturb me. If you would really understand truth, if you would know love, you must be free from beliefs and organized religions. There cannot be your religion and the religion of another, your beliefs and doctrines as against another. The world will be happy when there need be no preacher, when each individual is really fulfilling; and as he is not, I feel I can help him in his fulfillment.

If you feel that I am disturbing, creating sorrow, then you will naturally remain in the religion to which you belong, with its exploitations and illusions; but life will not leave you alone. In that lies the beauty of life. However much you have protected and enclosed yourself within certainties, securities, and beliefs, the wave of life breaks down all your structure. But the man who has no support, no security, shall know the bliss of life.

The Collected Works of J. Krishnamurti – Volume II 1934-1935: What Is Right Action?
Jiddu Krishnamurti

Just be happy

Robert Adams 20th Cent

When you concern yourself with your body, when you concern yourself with worldly conditions,
when you try to improve something,
all you’re doing is admitting that you are a fool.
In truth, this is all nonsense.
Everything is nonsense.

Therefore, why not be happy?
Why think about conditions, situations? Just be happy.
Do not try to analyze what happiness is. Do not even try to be happy.
Just be happy.

How do you become happy?
By not thinking.
If you have to think about it, it is not happiness.

The worst thing you can ever do is to try to change your condition, to be dissatisfied with the way things are.
Things are the way they’re supposed to be. Do not try to think about it or to analyze it. Things are exactly the way they’re
supposed to be. When you think about this you spoil it.
There are no mistakes.
No one is right, and no one is wrong.

~ The Collected Works of Robert Adams Volume 1, Chapter: The Body and the World

Inquiry into freedom JK

However much progress we may make in this world, however far we may go into the skies—visit the moon, Venus, and all the rest of it—the lives of most of us are still very shallow, superficial; they are still outward. And it is much more difficult to go inward; there is no technique for it, no professor to teach it, no laboratory where you can learn to travel within. There is no teacher who can guide you—and please believe me—there is no authority of any kind that can help you to investigate this complex entity called the mind. You have to do it entirely by yourself, without depending on a thing. And as modern civilization is becoming more and more complex, more and more outward, progressive, there is a tendency for all of us to live still more superficially, is there not? We attend more concerts, we read more clever books, we go endlessly to the cinema, we gather together to discuss intellectually, we investigate ourselves psychologically with the help of analysts, and so on; or, because we live such superficial lives, we turn to churches and fill our minds with their dogmas, both unreasonable and reasonable, with beliefs that are almost absurd; or we escape into some form of mysticism. In other words, realizing that our everyday living is shallow, most of us try to run away from it. We engage our minds in speculative philosophies or in what we call meditation, contemplation, which is a form of self-hypnosis; or, if we are at all intellectual, we create a thought-world of our own in which we live satisfied, intellectually content.

Seeing this whole process, it seems to me that the problem is not what to do, or how to live, or what is the immediate action to be taken when we are confronted with war, with the catastrophes that are actually going on in the world, but rather how to inquire into freedom. Because without freedom, there is no creation. By freedom I do not mean the freedom to do what you like—to get into a car and zip along a road, or to think what you like, or to engage yourself in some particular activity. It seems to me that such forms of freedom are not really freedom at all. But is there a freedom of the mind? As most of us do not live in a creative state, I think it is imperative for any thoughtful, serious man to inquire very profoundly and very earnestly into this question.

The Collected Works of
J. Krishnamurti –
Volume XI 1958-1960:
Crisis in Consciousness
Jiddu Krishnamurti

Truly listening rjs

There COULD be a most amazing surge in peace, love, mutual growth and understanding if people would always stretch beyond their last level of spiritual apprehension and ferret out what another is truly alluding to. Beyond pat answers and beyond pat reactions. Way way beyond and into rarefied place of finally forever free.

Emptiness, not knowledge RA

Knowledge seems to be destroying this world not making it a better place in which to live. The great secret is we have to unlearn everything we’ve learnt if we wish to become free and liberated. No matter how many times I say this to you, you’re still acquiring more knowledge, some of you. Think of the books you read recently. The news you’ve watched on TV. The newspapers you read. Aren’t you acquiring more and more knowledge? What is this knowledge doing for you? Expanding your ego and your ego grows and grows and encompasses the whole world, the whole universe. You have complete knowledge of the universe, of the world in which you live and you think this is going to free you. Freedom comes when you’re empty, when you know nothing. That’s when you’re free, completely absolutely free. Not when you accumulate knowledge yet you keep on doing it. And you will keep on doing it until life throws you around so much, that you’ll get disgusted with this world and start searching for answers within yourself.

Then you will know that you have to give up everything, not gain anything. You’ll have to drop everything you ever learnt. Everything that you’ve learnt in school, in your travels. All of this must be given up if you want to be free, if you want to be liberated. Liberation is your very nature, your swarrupa. Absolute reality is what you really are. Pure awareness. But it’s emptiness. These things are totally empty of anything. Pure awareness, absolute reality does not carry any knowledge to it. It does not contain any bit of knowledge whatsoever. It is emptiness. Total absolute emptiness. Emptiness is what makes the universe comes to pass. It is out of the emptiness that the universe grows. Everything comes from nothing.

Robert Adams

Transcript 225
Who Were You Before You Were Born?
21st February, 1993

Attachment

A T T A C H M E N T
● I can’t wait until . . . .
● I have to have . . . .
● This condition has to go . . . .
● S/He can’t treat me that way . . . .
● I must straighten out . . . .
● I Can’t stop thinking about . . . .
● This shouldn’t have happened . . . .
● I need to have that finished . . . .
● I won’t be happy until . . . .
● More . . . . . . . . . . . .

N O N – A T T A C H M E N T
Freedom!
Happiness now!
Contentment forever!
Peace!
Perfect Love!
Never needy!
Sublimity!
Self-containment!
Awakening!
Abundance!
Alertness!
Awareness!

DrRobinStarbuck